I was perusing the comments of PeteDorr’s most recent video — his top 10 games of 2025 — when I came across this comment made by Jojstin:
WE NEED ALL GEN GAMERS BACK! I will comment this on every video you, Johnny, John and Jason upload. Can we PLEASE get something, I beg of you Pete!
Somewhat delightfully, this became the busiest comment thread of the whole video! Some of the replies:
I 2nd this!
— TheKpierce
I 3rd this
— TheDach91
I have been saying this for years
— stephendrown3808
Now, I’m not going to get into my own opinions on whether or not AllGenGamers should attempt any kind of “reunion” today.1 But the next comment from earthboundgeek I thought was so cool to hear:
YES! I actually relistened to every All Gen Gamers episodes last year. It was so nostalgic for a better time in gaming, and Pete was always my favorite host.
If podcast listening had achievements, this is worthy of one, earthboundgeek.
And just within this little comment thread on a YouTube video having nothing to do with AGG, there are multiple people mentioning that they are or have been re-listening to some or all of the episodes. Jojstin mentions they are even going through this journey right now, and just finished Episode 20.2 I liked what they had to say about our “man of the sea”, so I’ll let them have the last word on this blog post:
I’m re-listening right now I’m on episode 20! It’s a nostalgic journey! Don’t forget to give that Whale some water every now and again.